home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=93TT1651>
- <link 93TO0092>
- <title>
- May 10, 1993: At The Center Of Power
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1993
- May 10, 1993 Ascent of a Woman: Hillary Clinton
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- COVER STORIES, Page 28
- At The Center Of POWER
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> The First Lady wants more than clout. She wants to have a
- life too. Can she find the formula?
- </p>
- <p>By MARGARET CARLSON WASHINGTON
- </p>
- <p> HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON knew life had changed forever when
- her daughter Chelsea got sick one night in February and asked
- her mother to fix one of her favorite dishes. No sooner did the
- First Lady pad down the hall to the kitchen on the second floor
- of the family quarters, open the refrigerator and begin
- cracking eggs than a steward appeared magically at her elbow.
- He wanted to help by whipping up an omelet. At the risk of
- hurting his feelings, the most influential woman in America
- explained that the eggs had to be scrambled and that she had to
- scramble them.
- </p>
- <p> Such are the days and nights of Hillary Rodham Clinton. In
- exchange for taking on the burdens of the world, including the
- most ambitious and powerful role a First Lady has ever assumed,
- all the practical considerations of daily living have been
- removed--whether she wants them to be or not. As she sits in
- the Library on the first floor of the residence after holding
- a reception for community volunteers on the South Lawn, a butler
- brings her iced tea on a silver tray, and with him the
- unmistakable formality of this old house with 132 rooms. She
- finally eats lunch that day at 3:30, looking almost too
- exhausted to chew, and admits it's been a "pretty stressful
- three months."
- </p>
- <p> Exhausting, yes, but also remarkable and historic. In her
- first 100 days, she has redefined the role of First Lady in
- America more than anyone would have imagined a year ago. By the
- end of this month, she plans to deliver a proposal for the
- largest piece of legislation since Social Security, a
- health-care plan that will affect one-seventh of the American
- economy. Her tackling of a nearly $1 trillion-a-year problem is
- accompanied by the sound of glass ceilings breaking as women
- empowered by the Clinton Administration rise to new positions
- of influence and opportunity. The new Attorney General, Janet
- Reno, last week demonstrated more courage and strength than any
- of her recent predecessors. At the same time, women in the armed
- forces celebrated a Pentagon decision to allow female pilots and
- sailors to go into combat. Topping it all off, the President
- boasted last week that women account for one-third of his
- nominees to top Administration jobs.
- </p>
- <p> Hillary is the first First Lady to have a major assignment
- by which she can--and will--be judged. As leader of a task
- force with a staff in excess of 500, she has traveled across
- nine states, held 50 congressional meetings and met with
- everyone from nurses to Native American spiritual healers. In
- a TIME/CNN poll, her popularity nearly matched her husband's:
- 55% viewed her favorably, vs. 61% for the President. In the
- survey 91% describe her as intelligent and 63% as a good
- influence on her husband on matters of national policy.
- </p>
- <p> To millions of women, Hillary Clinton's career-and-family
- balancing act is a symbolic struggle. Never mind that she has
- plenty of help, including more top officials on her staff than
- Al Gore has. Hillary still has something in common with women
- everywhere: a day that contains only 24 hours, and
- responsibilities that extend way beyond what happens in the
- office. Family duties fall primarily to her--from attending
- soccer games and helping Chelsea with her homework to shopping
- and organizing birthday parties. She's also looking after her
- mother, who is staying at the White House while recovering from
- the death of Hillary's 82-year-old father, Hugh Rodham. The
- First Lady's plea is familiar to any working woman. "We are
- trying to work it out that we have some more time just for
- ourselves. The job eats up every spare minute."
- </p>
- <p> The next few months will offer little respite. In the
- midst of the final marathon sessions to complete the task
- force's recommendations, the once rosy picture for pushing
- health-care reform through the Congress has turned bleak. House
- Ways and Means chairman Dan Rostenkowski went so far as to
- ridicule her nascent plan as the "domestic equivalent of Star
- Wars." (She still had him over for dinner that night.) A growing
- cabal of Administration officials has urged the Clintons to
- delay their health-care plan, arguing that the President can't
- risk overloading the system by sending both his economic and his
- health packages to Capitol Hill. But she is undaunted. The past
- two weeks have been a blur of 16-hour days, meetings for two and
- three hours at a clip with the health-care task force,
- interrupted by congressional briefings. She insists, "There is
- no delay in what we're doing."
- </p>
- <p> At the same time, the First Lady plays an up-front, active
- part in the presidency, from domestic affairs to political
- strategy to speech writing, bringing to the table two decades
- of experience and no apologies. In all but foreign affairs, she
- has emerged as First Adviser, being called in on the spur of the
- moment to a meeting of 15 senior staff members in late April,
- for example, to assess the problems of the first 100 days and
- the defeat of the President's stimulus package.
- </p>
- <p> While the whole world is watching to see how she pulls off
- her expanded role, she is also responsible for the traditional
- duties of a First Lady. Ceremonial events, like dinner for the
- country's Governors or tea with the King and Queen of Spain,
- don't stop because there is a deadline on managed competition.
- Paint chips and fabric swatches also fall under her
- jurisdiction. She is redecorating the private quarters to suit
- her informal style, which favors quilts and rocking chairs. She
- has already moved a table and white wicker chairs into the
- kitchen upstairs so that the family can eat breakfast and dinner
- in a cozier manner than the imposing dining room would permit.
- And she has had bedside phones installed that do not require
- going through a switchboard. "He sleeps here and has his phone,"
- she says, indicating one side of the queen-size bed. "And I
- sleep there and have mine." She furnished her husband's private
- study next to the Oval Office with a stand-up desk, a CD player,
- framed campaign buttons and a large portrait of herself.
- </p>
- <p> In an interview with TIME the First Lady is not the
- mechanical or rigid woman of her 60 Minutes appearance or of the
- early campaign. In the space of half an hour, she laughs
- heartily one minute, recalling a raucous lunch with her staff;
- then her face goes all to putty, and she has to apologize for
- choking up as she recalls someone's kindness in the aftermath
- of her father's death. She is happiest when she remembers time
- alone with the President: just the two of them on Valentine's
- Day going down to the movie theater to see The Bodyguard, and
- then off to the Red Sage restaurant for dinner, where the
- manager, Don Senich, estimates they touched more in two hours
- than the Bushes did in four years.
- </p>
- <p> Hillary's performance on her health-care road show is
- reminiscent of the campaign. She seems to be everywhere: at
- round, oval and U-shaped tables, with black briefing books,
- white papers and discussion points. At symposiums morning, noon
- and night, she presides with brow furrowed, lips pursed--sometimes speaking, sometimes listening, always taking notes.
- At hearings when 1,000 seats are available, gymnasiums have to
- be set up with closed-circuit TV to accommodate the overflow.
- In a field where there is little drama, she has interjected
- some, picking fights with her designated bullies of the system,
- the doctors and drug companies that have been making huge
- profits. Every witness has his or her own horror story about
- getting sick, and Hillary listens as if hearing such woe for the
- first time. When a woman named Kathy at hearings in Iowa talks
- about how she is frightened that she will never lead a normal
- life or pay for her care, Hillary exhorts the audience, "Let's
- give Kathy here a big hand for that speech." An hour later, the
- First Lady lambastes a private practitioner who is complaining
- about government regulation, and asks, Why can't you be part of
- the solution instead of part of the problem?
- </p>
- <p> Ever the best girl in class, there seems to be no fact she
- hasn't memorized. The minutiae of the Veterans hospital
- regulations? She can cite section and subsection. The incidence
- of diabetes among Indians in Montana? Forty percent, and there
- isn't a dialysis machine for hundreds of miles.
- </p>
- <p> While the public outside the Beltway has been included,
- the First Lady ran into controversy by trying to keep the task
- force's meetings behind closed doors. For a time, even the
- staff's names were secret. A running battle over the issue began
- when a group of doctors and industry insiders sued the White
- House to open the meetings, arguing that Hillary's presence as
- a nongovernment employee entitled them to attend as well. A
- federal judge ruled that some of the meetings had to be open.
- The Administration appealed, contending that it was only trying
- to keep lobbyists at bay.
- </p>
- <p> The First Lady has earned grudging respect on Capitol
- Hill, in part because she makes house calls. During her first
- visit, 30 Democratic Senators listened carefully, although most
- of them would rather have been having gum surgery. Her every
- misstep was discussed, from an overly familiar manner to her
- middle name, but she won points for her preparation and
- willingness to meet endlessly. Minority leader Bob Dole disputes
- press reports that Hillary blundered when she called him Bob.
- "Last time I checked," he said, "that was my name." And he calls
- her Hillary.
- </p>
- <p> By the time she went to brief the Senate Finance Committee
- at the end of April, she had learned the ropes. There is a rule
- on the Hill that if you can't explain it, you can't pass it.
- When she briefed the committee, the clarity of her pitch opened a
- few eyes. Says committee chief of staff Lawrence O'Donnell, a
- confirmed skeptic on Hillary's efforts: "I haven't been in the
- company of anyone that made me suspend my disbelief on health
- care until today. I'll come to my senses, but for the moment she
- was in the room, I believed she could do it."
- </p>
- <p> Outside her health-care mission, there is probably no
- title that could convey the scope of her role, although
- Counsellor to the President was batted around for a long time.
- As always, she is her husband's most trusted confidant, best
- friend, toughest critic and most ardent cheerleader. She is open
- but vague about how much they share. "We'll say, What do you
- think about this? or Give me an opinion about that. It's kind
- of give-and-take, pretty informal." And then there is complete
- access. "During the day I can see him anytime I want to. I can
- look out the window and see him," she says, smiling as she turns
- her head toward his office. "He's right there."
- </p>
- <p> When the presidential door closes, Hillary is behind it if
- she wants to be. "The President sits in the middle of the
- table, the Vice President right across from him, and Hillary
- wherever she wants," says an aide. "And the refrain we have all
- gotten used to is, `What do you think, Hillary?' " When the
- President's economic address to Congress was scraps of paper on
- the conference table in the Roosevelt Room, she stepped in and
- pasted it back together again. Aides are gradually becoming more
- open about Hillary's breadth. One says it goes like this: "A
- speech that needs a rewrite, get Hillary. A speech that needs
- to be given, get Hillary. The President has a problem he wants
- to chew over, get Hillary. The point is you never go wrong
- getting Hillary."
- </p>
- <p> The corridors of power are populated with many of
- Hillary's old friends, from White House counsel Bernard
- Nussbaum, who used to give his young law clerk Hillary a ride
- home when she first worked in Washington; to Deputy Attorney
- General Webb Hubbell, who was the managing partner of her law
- firm and the former mayor of Little Rock. Hillary had a strong
- say in the appointment of pal Donna Shalala as Health and Human
- Services Secretary, although the friendship grew complicated
- after Hillary grabbed the health out of the Secretary's title
- and Shalala blurted out that a value-added tax was being
- considered.
- </p>
- <p> With the power to make appointments comes the blame when
- many have gone unmade. The most visible unfilled post, chief of
- protocol, has already brought public embarrassment. While the
- Clintons have dithered over whether the job should go to a man
- or a woman, someone with Washington diplomatic experience or a
- Little Rock loyalist, events that should have garnered goodwill
- for the pair have sparked only resentment and enmity. The most
- disastrous incident occurred at the most important affair so
- far, a White House reception in honor of the opening of the U.S.
- Holocaust Museum. Scheduled to be there at 4 p.m., the President
- arrived 2 1/2 hours late. By that time, Polish President Lech
- Walesa, entertainer Mandy Patinkin, House Speaker Tom Foley and
- others had long run out of anything to say to one another and
- were squishing in the mud under a tent in a driving rain. Many
- of the older guests, Holocaust survivors, had left in disgust.
- </p>
- <p> When Hillary is going about her day, she acts like any
- other professional with a demanding, brain-crushing job. Her
- office in the West Wing is one of the least imposing, furnished
- with a blue-beige-and-red-striped sofa, a table submerged in
- paper, a small desk and a window looking out on a red tile roof.
- Hillary writes her own notes, has a cellular phone glued to her
- ear and makes many of her own calls. She goes through paperwork
- like butter, scribbling in the margins of the mail, trying not
- to touch the same piece twice. Says her deputy, Melanne
- Verveer: "I'm efficient, and she makes me look like a
- daydreamer."
- </p>
- <p> In the office Hillary presses coffee and bagels on the
- staff and frequently sends them home to bed and for holidays.
- White House political consultant Paul Begala says she is the one
- staff members go to when they have a problem. "I've never seen
- her lose her temper, and you can tell her anything." She
- approaches the outlandishly dressed youngsters on the White
- House staff to find out what the latest is from twentysomething
- land. One young man in a black, unstructured jacket mistakenly
- thought she was telling him to dress up when she said to him,
- "So this is the style now."
- </p>
- <p> In general, she stays away from irony, since humor has to
- watch its step in politics, avoiding off-the-cuff repartee that
- can look bad when repeated. Her whimsy runs more to
- lip-synching Baby, I Need Your Loving and giving a tour of the
- White House the way Alistair Cooke might guide visitors around
- Windsor Castle. Her style with her personal staff is collegial,
- and she doesn't stand on ceremony. Says her chief of staff,
- Maggie Williams: "If the top person isn't around when Hillary
- has something to go over, she is ready to do business with a
- deputy. A schedule change? She says, `Tell me who's coming and
- what I need to do.' " When nothing is going right and it's gray
- outside, and it will be another late workday, she's the one who
- says, "Let's go eat," and everyone troops down to the mess for
- taco salad and Oreo yogurt.
- </p>
- <p> Even so, some people are scared to death of her. One aide
- says the problem comes in mixing up "formidable" with
- "frightening." He says, "She has all the protective, wifely
- instincts of, say, Nancy Reagan, but then on top of that she is
- very smart, and so nothing gets by her, nothing." Hillary even
- took a hand in making office assignments for the West Wing. "We
- were looking at this floor plan and, presto, she had a layout
- it would have taken an industrial engineer weeks to figure. Not
- everybody was happy, but she got it right." Hillary does not
- take kindly to detours off the main road when a discussion is
- under way. Says close friend and former campaign scheduler Susan
- Thomases: "Hillary is a closer. She does not let things drag
- on." Another observes that "when Hillary leans forward, puts her
- elbows on the table in front of her and hunches her shoulders
- ever so slightly, this is international sign language for, `Be
- quiet.' "
- </p>
- <p> Last week the Clintons reversed their usual roles. Both
- were trapped for hours at a time in the Roosevelt Room for the
- final presentations of the task-force leaders, when one of the
- briefers droned on about five minutes too long. Hillary started
- reading her notes, obviously impatient, but she left it to her
- husband to circle his arm in the air to get the guy to move it
- along.
- </p>
- <p> Hillary's open involvement in policymaking disturbs some
- Republicans and others who feel duped by the Hillary Lite that
- emerged in the latter stages of the campaign after polling found
- that voters were fearful of what pollsters termed an "empowered
- Nancy Reagan." If she had her fingers crossed when she was
- nodding sweetly, baking chocolate-chip cookies and calling
- herself Hillary Clinton, how many other things might be fudged
- for political expediency? Republican fund raisers such as Floyd
- Brown see a bait-and-switch tactic that they hope to capitalize
- on by portraying her as massively influencing everything from
- the appointment of the deputy assistant undersecretary for
- technology transfer to a decision on whether the U.S. should
- bomb Serbian artillery lines. In his newsletter, Clinton Watch,
- Brown calls the President "a captive of the radical left, of
- which his boss, Hillary, is a member in good standing."
- </p>
- <p> A Republican consultant told a network newscaster that his
- job was to make sure Hillary Clinton is discredited before the
- 1996 campaign. Each day anti-Hillary talking points go out to
- talk-show hosts. The rumor machine is cranking out bogus stories
- about her face (lifted), her sex life (either nonexistent or all
- too active) and her marriage (a sham). Many of the stories are
- attributed to the Secret Service in an attempt to give the tales
- credibility. She denies the yarn about her throwing a lamp (or
- Bible or vase), then wonders about the sources. "Why are they
- telling lies about me? What is it about me? It's strange.
- Obviously something has to be going on. People are out there
- trying to promote this."
- </p>
- <p> Part of what allows the rumors to grow is that they arrive
- in a vacuum. She is relatively closed next to her husband's
- wide-eyed openness. The public has an encyclopedic knowledge of
- the President's habits, from his favorite teams to how long he
- jogs, his weakness for junk food and the eggs with jalapeno
- peppers he fixes for Hillary. He will answer the most personal
- questions if they are put directly to him. When the story gets
- around that a steward inadvertently walked into the presidential
- bedroom while the Clintons were still asleep, Clinton said it
- was true but "not as lusty as it sounds."
- </p>
- <p> Hillary has yet to adjust to the notion that every waking
- moment of a First Lady--and some of the sleeping ones--is
- public property. Friends say Hillary fenced off a park of
- privacy right after the notorious broadcast of 60 Minutes, when
- almost every frame of tape showing her at her best was left on
- the cutting-room floor. After that, friends say, she adopted the
- attitude that the less of her that is known, the less there is
- for the press to pick apart. She is jealous of her husband's
- privacy as well, complaining that he can't go watch Chelsea's
- softball games because he would be dogged by the press. "They
- leave Al and Tipper alone. I mean, Al and Tipper go to all their
- kids' games. And I think Bill deserves to have some of that same
- space and have some normal family life."
- </p>
- <p> Her reticence is a departure, given the open life she
- lived for a decade in the Governor's mansion in Little Rock. She
- drove her own Oldsmobile, waited in line at the movies,
- entertained in the kitchen and had the church choir over for
- picnics in the backyard. She purposely sent the household staff
- off on weekends so she could go to the grocery store on Saturday
- mornings. In a state where Gloria Steinem was considered by some
- a communist, Hillary started out being regarded as a stuck-up
- feminist from Wellesley and Yale who wouldn't change her name
- and ended up a popular and admired First Lady.
- </p>
- <p> Now, Hillary wants to preserve some part of the prosaic
- quality of life so Chelsea doesn't grow up believing food just
- magically materializes on her plate. They went to the grocery
- store together, one day after Hillary picked up Chelsea from
- school, to get peanut butter and cereal, only to find that they
- had insufficient cash and no checkbook. Lately the First Mom has
- been helping her daughter make the perilous journey from age 12
- to 13 in a new city without the close-knit extended family and
- friends of Little Rock. The elder Rod hams had stayed in the
- Governor's mansion with Chelsea when her parents were away, and
- the death of her grandfather added to the trauma of the move.
- Most days Hillary ends her work in time to be upstairs when
- Chelsea gets home from school. During the blizzard in March,
- Hillary stayed in the family quarters with Chelsea on her day
- off. They organized her room, made lunch, watched a movie and
- played Chelsea's Game Boy, to which Hillary promptly became
- addicted.
- </p>
- <p> While Hillary generally shrugs off criticism about
- herself, the treatment of Chelsea is another matter. Hillary
- took out after Saturday Night Live producer Lorne Michaels and
- his writers for "having nothing better to do than be mean and
- cruel to a young girl," after they ran a skit making fun of her
- daughter.
- </p>
- <p> Hillary had her own perilous journey as she sat for over
- two weeks watching her father--the gruff, authoritarian and
- inspiring Hugh Rod ham--slowly slip away. She comes from a
- family so bizarrely intact that the whole group went on the
- Clintons' honeymoon to Acapulco. The extended family had dinner
- together most weekends and played marathon games of Trivial
- Pursuit and Hungarian rummy, a card game so byzantine in its
- bylaws that only close friends or relatives can participate.
- </p>
- <p> Hillary was at lunch in the White House mess in March when
- Carolyn Huber, the former administrator of the Governor's
- mansion, walked in. When Huber bent over and whispered in her
- ear, Hillary's face turned white. That afternoon she and Chelsea
- left for St. Vincent Infirmary in Little Rock, and the President
- arrived two days later. Hillary made it to her father's bedside
- in time to say goodbye. "When we got there, for the first couple
- of days," she recalls, "he knew we were there, and it was
- wonderful." She returned to Washington after 16 days, just as
- her husband returned from the Yeltsin summit. The next day she
- was scheduled to throw out the first ball of the Chicago Cubs
- opener with her father, who had taken her to games at Wrigley
- Field as a girl and stuffed her with hot dogs and statistics.
- She canceled.
- </p>
- <p> She did not cancel a commitment to address the University
- of Texas at Austin, speaking for half an hour without notes and
- with uncharacteristic emotion. She cited the observations of
- Bush campaign manager Lee Atwater as he lay dying from a brain
- tumor at age 40: "My illness helped me to see that what was
- missing in society is what was missing in me--a little heart, a
- lot of brotherhood...And to see that we must be made to
- speak to this spiritual vacuum at the heart of American
- society, this tumor of the soul." She posed the questions of her
- own vigil: "When does life start? When does life end? Who makes
- those decisions, and how do we dare impinge upon these areas of
- such delicate, difficult questions?" Her father died the next
- day.
- </p>
- <p> Back at the White House, the Clintons have tried to
- re-create a down-home atmosphere. The solarium sometimes
- substitutes for the huge kitchen in Little Rock where most of
- their entertaining was done. It is where overnight guests gather
- for breakfast. Arkansas-born actress Mary Steenburgen, who spent
- the night in the Lincoln Bedroom on her birthday, is the only
- guest so far to jump into the outdoor pool. When Norman Lear
- came for dinner, the President wore sneakers and dinner was
- chicken enchiladas. One night when Arkansas Senator David Pryor
- was over, he insisted the President go to bed, only to have
- Clinton try to drag him downstairs to see Steve Martin's Leap
- of Faith. The Clintons went out with the Gores one evening in
- leather jackets and jeans to a Virginia bar to hear Jerry Jeff
- Walker and drink Molsons.
- </p>
- <p> Not that Hillary lacks regard for White House tradition.
- She has taken to her role like a student, reading 43 White
- House biographies and numerous histories (she impressed the
- White House Historical Association over tea with all her facts).
- She has debriefed other First Ladies, including Jacqueline
- Kennedy Onassis during lunch in her Fifth Avenue apartment.
- </p>
- <p> Yet Hillary is in a position no First Lady has ever
- experienced. As the icon of American womanhood, she is the
- medium through which the remaining anxieties over feminism are
- being played out. She is on a cultural seesaw held to a
- schizophrenic standard: everything she does that is soft is a
- calculated coverup of the careerist inside; everything that
- isn't is a put-down of women who stay home and bake cookies. As
- she sits in the White House on a spring day, she seems to be
- bending with the burden, more relaxed and philosophical about
- what life is throwing at her than anyone would have predicted
- from her press clips. She is less the killer lawyer than a
- version of the modern mother, daughter, wife and professional
- trying to fill all roles at once, and perfectly, but resigned
- to imperfection. "I'm not one of these Energizer Bunnies," she
- says.
- </p>
- <p> In her Texas speech, her voice halted as she quoted the
- admission by Atwater that he had acquired all the wealth and
- prestige he had wanted and still felt empty. "What power
- wouldn't I trade for a little more time with my family? What
- price wouldn't I pay for an evening with friends." Last Thursday
- evening as the sun was going down, the President emerged from
- a meeting on Bosnia to join his wife. They hadn't seen each
- other for a few hours, and in the shadows behind the door of the
- diplomatic entrance, he touched the side of her face and took
- her hand before they came out to say goodbye to the 500 members
- of the health-care task force gathered on the South Lawn. He
- thanked them, and then turned and said, "I'm indebted once again
- to my wonderful wife." It's a line uttered by politicians since
- the Republic was formed, but he may just mean it.
- </p>
- <p> Perhaps in addition to the other items on her agenda,
- Hillary Rodham Clinton will define for women that magical spot
- where the important work of the world and love and children and
- an inner life all come together. Like Ginger Rogers, she will
- do everything her partner does, only backward and in high
- heels, and with what was missing in Atwater--a lot of heart.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-